
Mari
From Zenit
Pope John Paul II contemplated the possibility of resigning but decided against it for fear of creating a "dangerous precedent for his successors."
So revealed his longtime private secretary, Archbishop Stanislaw Dziwisz, to Cardinal Julin Herranz, president of the Pontifical Council for the Interpretation of Legislative Texts, on Dec. 17, 2004.
Cardinal Herranz has now revealed the contents of that conversation in a book entitled "Nei Dintorni de Gerico. Ricordi degli Anni con San Josemaria & con Giovanni Paolo II" (In the Surroundings of Jericho: Memories of the Years with Saint Josemara and John Paul II), published by Ares in Milan. The book records his memories of times spent with the founder of Opus Dei and with the Polish Pontiff.
Commenting on the "famous Canon 332," which in the Code of Canon Law refers to the possibility of papal resignation, Cardinal Herranz quoted the phrases he himself wrote after his conversation with Archbishop Dziwisz.
"We spoke of the opinion I expressed to him -- at his request -- on the appropriateness of the Holy Father resigning on his 75th or 80th birthday. I answered that he 'should not' do so for reasons of age: Very different is the 'canonical mission' that Bishops receive from the Pope to govern a particular Church or diocese with respect to the mission that the Pope receives at the very moment of the election and acceptance."
Heroic obedience
On Page 451 of his book, Cardinal Herranz explains that the apostolic constitution "Universi Dominici Gregis" emphasizes that "it is a doctrine of faith that the authority of the Supreme Pontiff derives directly from Christ, of whom he is Vicar on earth," though elected by the cardinals.
"In regard to the possibility of resigning for reasons of health, I wrote in that note something which I now think is opportune to make known, as an example of the heroic obedience and prudence of John Paul II," revealed Cardinal Herranz.
Archbishop Dziwisz "limited himself to comment that 'the Pope -- who is personally very detached from the office -- lives abandoned to the Will of God. He places himself in the hands of Divine Providence.'"
"'Moreover,'" he quoted Archbishop Dziwisz as saying, "'he is afraid of creating a dangerous precedent for his successors, as some one of them might be exposed to subtle maneuvers and pressures by those who wish to depose him.'"
www.zenit.org/english/visualizza.phtml?sid=83539
Do people have any views on this? Should it be possible for a pope to resign?




